Podcast: Spooky One-Liners and Bags of Cash: Why NIL Is Really an Entrepreneurship Story (Live from SMA)

Recorded live at the Southern Management Association conference in St. Pete, this episode opens with a spooky special: the one-liners that haunt every workplace. “Do you have a minute?” “We’re like a family here.” “Reviewer 2 has some concerns.” “The Dean would like to see you.” The audience adds a few of their own, including the instant classic “It doesn’t matter to me, but other people are talking about this.” Along the way, a room full of business school faculty discovers that none of them can say what AACSB stands for.

Then Jake Waddingham of Texas State University joins Frank and Paul to explain why name, image, and likeness (NIL) is really an entrepreneurship story. NIL turned college athletes into brand builders almost overnight, but four out of five NCAA athletes aren’t business majors, and most were never taught how to spot opportunities, read a contract, or say no to a bad deal.

In this episode:

  • Spooky office and academic one-liners, from “I’ll loop you in” to “Your committee would like you to add one more study”
  • Why reply-all is the true horror of academic life, and the committee on committees
  • What NIL is, and how college sports went from “no free bagels” to million-dollar deals almost overnight
  • From bags of cash to booster collectives: where the money comes from, and why donors keep giving to players who may be gone in a year
  • Why the average NIL numbers mislead, and why gymnasts, soccer players, and runners lack the agent networks football and basketball players have
  • Bad actors, high agent fees, restrictive contracts, and learning that it’s okay to say no
  • How business students can act as pseudo-agents, and how NIL projects can work as internships for athletes who can’t take one
  • Sports gambling, fan pressure, and what it does to student athletes
  • Why the NIL playbook can work for musicians, fashion designers, and other entrepreneurial students

Guest:
Jake Waddingham holds the Hunnicutt Professorship in Management at Texas State University’s McCoy College of Business. His research explores NIL, entrepreneurship, and how student athletes build and manage their personal brands.

Thank you:
Thanks to Jake, the Hunnicutt Professorship in Management, and the Texas State McCoy College of Business for sponsoring this episode. Thanks also to our SMA audience for the great questions, and to Endia for running the mic once again.

Come visit us at busynessparadox.com to see episode transcripts,  blog posts and other content while you’re there!

Live from SMA 2026

00:00:00 Frank Butler: Yep. Hello busy bodies. Welcome to another episode of The Busyness Paradox. I am Frank Butler here with Paul Harvey. Good day Frank. Good day, Paul, and welcome to your most irregularly regular podcast, The Busyness Paradox. Um, today we’re, we’re live from SMA. We are greatly, uh, thankful for the support from Texas State University for sponsoring this, this episode. Uh, Jake Waddingham from there will be joining us later. But until then, we figured we’re going to go with a special spooky Halloween edition. Since we are coming up on Halloween, it’s probably worth mentioning as we record this, it’s October twenty ninth. So yeah, it is Halloween spirit down here in Clearwater, Florida. Saint Pete, whatever the name of this town is, it feels very halloweeny, doesn’t it? Feels warm. Frankly it doesn’t. Because of this swank. What have you got me? But but Paul’s wearing a hoodie in Florida, so just just some insights there. So. You ready? Ready ready. All right. So what we’re going to do on this episode is, like I said, we’re going to start with some spooky kind of things. And one of the ideas we had was to talk about spooky one liners in the office. And a great example of that one is if somebody comes up to you and says, do you have a minute? This is where we need the sound effect. Oh, just a quick question. Just a quick question. Is it ever quick? Sure, the answer takes forty five minutes and several follow ups, but the question’s quick. It’s very, very much on point. So for the audience, were there ever any one liners that you can think of that would be an example of one of those, oh boy, this is going to get scary. These are the words I don’t want to hear. We need to talk about the previous meeting. Oh man, that one cut deep. I just shivered up here, man. That sends a chill down my spine. Your boss asked for a meeting at four o’clock on a Friday. Mhm. Uh, you know, that’s never going to end well, is it? You get the email at four fifty five and it’s like, hey, I need some changes to that PowerPoint. Mhm. It doesn’t really matter to me. But other people are talking about this. I think you need to drop the mic on that one. That was that just you can’t really add to that. No. And those are the kinds of things that man, they just send shivers down our spines. And you just know you’re in for a you’re in for a real treat. Here’s another one that I always like. We’re like a family here. Mhm. You know that. You hear that? You know you’re doomed. It always means like the Manson family. Not like the good kind of family. You know? We’re genetically similar in our sociopathy. Yeah. Oh, man. That that went a little left there, didn’t it? Yeah, yeah. Sorry. I took that one to a dark place. Or reel it back in. I think we need to take that one offline. Uh, but, you know, actually. So that’s those are the office space ones. But let’s, let’s talk about academia. We have no shortage of one liners that haunt all of us in some way, shape or form. So one of my, uh, one of my particular favorites is you, you get your review back and you’re reading it and the editor says, reviewer two has some concerns. You know, you’re done. Mhm. The worst, I think. Well, not the worst, but when. Reviewer two like comes back from the dead like a separate a different submission and you’re like, I know you. And you still want me to cite that damn nineteen eighty seven study, even though it’s a totally different topic? Yeah. Ironically, we were told by one of our editorial or one of the, our, uh, I think it’s Emerald. They were like, you guys need to stop that. There’s, there’s been a trend of that going on where reviewers are saying cider stuff that doesn’t really fit. So it’s been, it’s been an interesting thing to get that. Um, apparently another. Apparently our field is not immune to that, but apparently it’s much worse than other fields. Something I’ve learned recently that what do they call it? Um, it’s like for citation or something like that coercive citation or something to that effect. Oh yeah. Yeah. Apparently it’s like rampant in some fields. It apparently has become quite rampant. Um, And you know, that’s neither here nor there. That’s a good thing. But here’s to kind of clamp down on that. But here, here are a couple other other one liners. Um, a, a CSB is coming. Yeah. For the non-academic listener, Aacsb stands for what? Uh, I don’t even know. Association of accredited colleges, colleges and businesses. I don’t even know. Does anybody know what it actually, the devil’s work, the devil’s work, the devil’s work. That’s what we got from the audience. And that is, uh. I don’t remember if it was me that made this up or someone else that I work with, but someone referred to it as a, um, like a bureaucratic talent show, like put on putting on a dog and pony show for like professional bureaucrats is how you get accredited. So like, can you show that you documented the process of documenting processes and have a committee that ensures the ongoing improvement of the process documentation process. That’s how you get accredited. We’re doomed. Oh, you have you have what it stands for. Association to advance collegiate schools of business. Oh, we were way off. Yeah, we were pretty far off. I love that, though. We’re close. That’s room full of academics. Not one of us is all that Aacsb accredited institutions. No less. Um, that’s actually kind of embarrassing. We all, like, served on committees for that. Literally I have. Yes. Um. Oh, goodness. That was. That’s actually terrible. Um, here’s another one for you guys. The dean would like to see. I see Paul Johnson over here nodding his head. He’s an associate dean. He knows exactly that one. I like this one. The dark side to their Frank. I know I’m going to be the one sending that email. Well, maybe, um, I’ll try not to be that guy, but I think I think you just turn into. It just happens. Um, here’s one that I think a lot of us can, uh, can relate to. This would be a great service opportunity for you junior faculty. I know that one. You go, uh, I’ve got I know there’s a couple in here. Another one I kind of always stress about. And fortunately, we’ve only had to do this once, but we’re switching learning management systems. That is the most painful two, three years that you’ll go through in academia. I feel like, I don’t know, for us, like from the burning embers of blackboard, switching to canvas was actually pretty pleasant. Yeah, no canvas was a huge upgrade over blackboard, but still that transition was not seamless, right? It’s not like the four letter word of dash for the state of Tennessee, but we’re not even going to go there. That’s a four letter word in Tennessee. So tell us more about Daesh. No, you don’t want to just know it’s synonymous with crap. But you know, um. But yeah, no, uh, the, the other one is, uh, your committee would like you to add one more study. Um, you know, if you’re working on your dissertation, uh, dissertation committee. Yep, yep. One more study. So anyway, any, any, any from the audience that they have that they’ve heard in their academic careers that’s gotten them shivery. Oh, here we go. Very short one. I get a lot of emails with thoughts, question mark thoughts. Oh, goodness. Your study has potential, but we don’t like your theory. Mhm, mhm. Back to the drawing board. Ouch. Yeah. That’s a that’s that’s a rewrite there, isn’t it? And then the other reviewer says your theory has potential. But we don’t like your methods, right? That’s that’s actually very true too. Um, are we also talking one liners from students because I have. Yes. Go for it. Yeah, go for it. Will this be on the exam? Mhm. Mhm. Mhm. That one hurts. Um, that one stings a little bit. Ah. They ask you a question that’s like clearly answered in the syllabus. Yeah, I think so. Syllabus reading is a dead art. I think it just doesn’t happen anymore. I want to I want to drop syllabus and just say reading is a dead art. Yeah, yeah, I think that’s true. And that’s actually kind of, I think, spookier than anything else that we might even talk about today. Yeah, that’s not scary. That just put a downer on the room there, didn’t it? I think we all just went, uh, let’s wrap this up. Come on. So there’s a, there’s a couple that that I thought were interesting too. Like that’s not even like words, right? Going into this idea of sounds that you might hear that add to your scaredness or aspect of it, a leaf blower while you’re recording a podcast, leaf blower, recording a podcast, or how about the chainsaw? Wherever the hell that is? I think that’s a leaf blower. Yeah, yeah. Hopefully it doesn’t pick up in the background. I’m sure we’re okay. Yeah, but how about the calendar invite with no agenda? Um, I’m sure we’ve all gotten that one in the past. You just ding up the team’s ringtone at four fifty five on a Friday. It kind of goes to what Paul was talking about it, you know, uh oh, this is this one. This one. This one really annoys me to no end. And that is the reply all that. There is nothing that makes me more furious than an email goes out to the entire college and the next thing you know, you have a bunch of people who just have to have their. You have to see their response, get their two cents in. It’s a proven fact. I don’t know if you know this, Frank, that every time you hit reply all a kitten dies. That just made that really. Which is a classic meme that I. Now she’s now my department chair. But then junior faculty member in our department sent that and like response to his reply all change hit reply all and just a picture of the meme. It’s like these two kittens and it says every time you hit reply all kitten dies. And ever since then, it’s kind of become a running joke in our department. I think what we need to do is print that out and hand out copies to every person in the college for training purposes. You know, it’s like, oh, so and so is, uh, you know, taking a new job. And then everybody has the need to say congratulations to the entire. I mean, I, I always take it to just sending them the email saying, congratulations, that’s great. I’m happy for you. I don’t need to see the four thousand. Ding ding ding. Nope. Especially if you have the like, thing on your phone that buzzes. Nope. Yeah. No. Absolutely. Buzz buzz buzz buzz. Yeah. I’m going to be contrarian here. I think it’s a great way to identify the people I don’t want to be around. Oh that’s true. Oh. Now. Oh. So see there’s always an upside. Leave it to Paul. I actually appreciate that. It’s true. It’s like I know that they’re going to be insufferable. Right? I can’t figure out reply all. Yeah. And then we’re going to move into, uh, the busyness paradox side of things. You know, those those are the ones that sound like productivity, but they’re really busyness, which is a thing I’ve been, like, rattling around in my brain lately. Maybe we’ll do a full episode on this. I feel like some jobs that are not academic jobs, like administrative jobs, non producing type jobs, like for some people, like email volume is kind of a proxy for how productive you are. Whereas for us it’s just cognitive switching, exhaustion, producing madness. I don’t know, that’s just a theory. I’ve been sort of like bubbling around in my head lately. I think I think we’re going to have to work on. Yeah. Incubate that. Yes, I agree on that one. Uh, this was this one’s one of those that came up. Let’s schedule a meeting to plan the meeting. Mhm. And I think, you know, what I always like to use is that we have a committee on committees at the university, which is just, to me, the most hilariously named committee. The sad thing is, it can kind of understand why there is a committee on committees at schools, but there are so many committees that you kind of do need something to rein them all in. Death by committee. Right by committee. Yep, yep. So that’s that was one of those. The other ones. I’ll loop you in. Mhm. Why don’t you just have me at the meeting in the first place and save us all a bunch of time? Right. That’s that’s always the one that’s like. I think you just went through this India where you had somebody who met and you’re like, make sure to include me. And they’re like, no. And then they got it all screwed up. So now you have to have another meeting with that person. Oh, three more meetings, three more meetings. What was that quick clip we’re talking about in the last episode, I think, uh, like, what are your thoughts on the meeting? You weren’t invited. The decision that was made at the meeting you weren’t invited to or something. That’s right. That’s right. Yeah, we were doing that on our last episode. Right? I think so, yeah, that I think that was it. Um, we need more visibility on this. What does that even mean? I just, I don’t know. And then so anyway, those are some of those ideas that keep popping up. Any, any other favorites that you guys have come across that that might have been a one liner that you go, you know, life is going to not be great for the moment. Oh, we got one out there. I’m still reeling from that. Walters uh, doesn’t matter to me. But other people are saying that that one really hit home. That may be the one. Um, let’s form a committee to investigate whatever Dems are fighting words instead of just making a decision, let’s form a committee and drag this out for three months because no decision by committee has ever been bad. Well, that’s a great way to have things not get done. That is from a Dean’s perspective. I’d love putting committees together for because if I don’t want something to happen, put in a committee. It’s like, what’s. What’s the term for that? Filibustering? Yes, yes. The filibustering. You can even if you want to get really crazy about it, you know who exactly who to put on those committees. That’s true. Yeah, I know exactly who will not get this done in a very long amount of time. We need to discuss it more in our next meeting. Yeah, yeah, that just with the hidden implication that there’s going to be a next meeting. Yeah. Ah, you know, that’s another two hours of your life you’re not getting back. So, um, well, with that, uh, we appreciate the spooky side. Now we’re going to get back to the business side. We got Jake here. Now. He’s joining us from another session. First of all, thank you for sponsoring this episode of The Busyness Paradox. Of course. Happy to be here. Um, have to shout out Texas State University and the Honeycut Professor of Management for helping make all this possible. But really excited to, to be here and talk with you guys. Look at that. The honeycut. That’s hey, I like that. That sounds good. Um, so you we had talked about it briefly, uh, when you sponsored this about, uh, talking about Nil and entrepreneurship. That seems to be where your research is currently trending, right? Definitely an area of interest that I’m having fun exploring. We should probably define that for folks who don’t know what Nil is. Yeah. So Nil is going to be the thing that is making everyone upset on college game day Saturdays its name, image and likeness. And it is where college athletes can now monetize and make money based on their personal brand. And it has allowed them to be a lot more entrepreneurial with how they go about their football or sports careers. And it also allows them to put together some interesting packages for recruiting and retention. And for those who aren’t avid college sports fans, like, it’s hard to overstate how much of a departure from history this has been for like the last one hundred years. It’s like you got a free soda because you’re an athlete. Like you’re banned. You can’t play for the next year. You got to sit out six games or something ridiculous. Now it’s like, all right, back up the truck. You know, seven million dollars. You got it. Like there was no like transition. It just went from absolutely. You cannot get a bagel with cream cheese on it to. Wide open, wide open, and then that recruit can leave the next year with no penalty, no penalties. It’s been a real Wild West that they’re trying to navigate. I think that’s the thing that bothers me the most is the whole leaving without penalty. I think these should be more kind of contractual nature. Hey, you stay for three years of eligibility. You know, we’ll continue to support that. But I also get the flip side too, because then that adds additional contractual issues of what if your performance really stinks and you don’t turn out to be that five star or what have you. You know, there’s a lot of a lot of issues that you deal with that maybe the pros are not dealing with because a lot of five stars don’t turn out. You know, they, they, on paper, their, their high school, whatever they, they seem like the second coming of, you know, Peyton Manning. And then it just doesn’t work out for whatever reason. Yeah. And you also have external factors as well. If you have an eighteen year old kid with two million dollars now, and they may not just have the, the training or the knowledge of that financial literacy. They may have a coach that leaves that’s, you know, their developmental component of it or just a major culture shift where it’s it seems like it’s a good fit on paper, but it’s really not. And now they do have an avenue to leave, which is good, but they also don’t get that resiliency either climbing the depth chart or working through that different tournament to I mean, it’s really easy to like, talk about the downsides of all this, but it is kind of nice to see these kids finally getting paid because they do produce just mountains of cash for universities and affiliated businesses. But yeah, like you said, it’s we’re kind of in an interesting period of history where like, it’s probably not going to be Wild West forever, but we don’t quite know what’s coming next. Now, there’s been this House bill that passed, I’m not sure. I guess it goes to the Senate that’s putting some limits right on, like the number of times you can transfer schools and things like that. I don’t know what’s going to come of that, but I don’t know. You might have given you might be more kind of in tune to that. Do you think that’s the next step in this process. Or I think that’s why it’s a great research topic. Yeah. Especially for organizational behavior strategy, entrepreneurship across the board. Um, what you’re talking about is a huge institutional change. Yeah. And once that institutional shock comes in, that’s going to drastically change how they start to think about development and recruitment again. Yeah. The, the other house, the NCAA, um, change drastically changed the revenue sharing structure and how much, you know, universities can now directly pay athletes instead of them having to go through the Nil route. Um, and so we had these big institutional shocks are going to be things that are going to have to navigate, um, as both players and, and figuring out what they want to do and programs, trying to figure out how to build and continue to maintain that level of excellence when there’s so much money going into it. Yeah. And I know this is a contentious topic, but it kind of seems like certain challenges really won’t be able to be addressed unless they go all in and call the students employees and allow them to unionize. Collective bargaining. That’s how you kind of get to what, you know, professional sports leagues have, where both sides kind of can negotiate as two separate entities like players and universities in this case. But boy, are there a lot of complications with that. I remember listening to an interview with Notre Dame’s former athletic director. Swarbrick, I think, was his name, and he was kind of like most athletic directors of the ante, not in favor of student athletes unionizing. And the the interviewer was kind of taking the other side of the argument. And he said something about, you know, the players like angry with a coach or something like, wouldn’t that give them a route to address that grievance? He said, well, no, they go through HR because they’d be they’d be employees at that point. And the interviewer, you could tell just kind of like, oh, like you can’t take just the parts that you want. You have to go all in. If their employees, their employees all the way through, um, is that something that you’ve looked at in your research? Like the possibility of collective bargaining in the future in this? Not necessarily on that side of it. I think the area I’ve leaned into a little bit more, um, has been most of the conversation, even the conversation we’ve started today has really been focused on football. That’s where a lot of the money is. That’s where a lot of the the attention and the headlines go. Um, but a women’s basketball player can be just as successful in this or, you know, a gymnast or, you know, the Texas State mariachi band. Um, there are a ton of options where now that Nil has unlocked a marketplace where we can assign value to these brands that students, athletes and, and just general students can build. Um, there needs to be some resources to help them do that. Um, four out of five NCAA athletes are not business majors, and so they don’t have the education, the background, the knowledge of how to identify these entrepreneurial opportunities. And I think it’s a chance for us to step in and, and help them with that. Um, TCU and Alabama, Oklahoma State are doing some awesome work of creating student organizations where student athlete schedules are crazy. They are students and they have to go to class, but then they have training and rehab and all these other responsibilities they have for their sport, and then they have to go be entrepreneurs on top of that and try to build their brand. And so marketing students or, you know, PR students, business students can help act as kind of pseudo agents or, you know, help them with that side of the business. Um, and that’s where, you know, as, as scholars and educators, we can really step in and help level the playing field a little bit because the football and men’s basketball, they’re going to get paid, they’re going to get their money. Um, they tend to have a little bit more access to the professional agent network. Um, but our gymnast, our soccer players, our cross country runners, uh, don’t have that infrastructure to be able to figure out how to navigate this space. Good point. And you hear stories that apparently, you know, that the professional agent class is quite aware of all this. And you get some shady characters out there apparently, like. I don’t know if these are the exact numbers, but I think like in the NFL, National Football League agents, uh, whatever you call it, commission is capped at something like three percent of the contract’s value. There’s no such caps in the college Nil game currently. So apparently the average is like fifteen percent or something like five times what NFL agents are making. And these are eight, seventeen, eighteen year old kids that they don’t know any better. You’re absolutely right. And without that regulation or that cap, um, we also see, unfortunately, a lot of bad actors that are also family members. You know, the uncle comes in and he didn’t get his shot at his football career or his basketball career, but now he, of course, knows how to navigate it and advise it. And he’s in the player’s ear. And you could you could go out west and get a lot more money. And I’m going to take fifteen percent of it because of course I advise you to do it. Yep. Um, and so again, when we’re talking about these young individuals just starting kind of this professional navigation, they may not be getting the best advice either. Um, and so when you get really mad at your star quarterback for leaving, there might have been somebody else in his ear that made it more toxic than the program or the team you root for. It’s a good point. So there really is a vacuum that we could fill, which. Now I feel like it’s our problem. I do know that I’ve heard other schools have been planning programming around student athlete like business, right? Like some sort of minor or those kinds of things that are specific for the student athlete. And because of the N I l state coming in, I think these early adopters, so to speak. It’ll be interesting to see how they play out because it’s still too early, I think, to see the success of these. Right. The efficacy of it. Yeah. And there’s just such a wide range of success and non success. If you look at the numbers of how much these, you know, student athletes are bringing in, um, the NCAA loves to say like, oh, we’re averaging about, you know, twenty five, thirty thousand dollars for our student athletes. That’s the average, which means Arch Manning and the others are pulling that average way high. Um, you got ten guys making ten million dollars a year and everyone else is getting peanuts. Exactly. And so the average NCAA student is barely making that six hundred dollars threshold where they even have to report it. Wow. And so even though it feels like nil is everywhere, the transfer portal is affecting everything. It really is the lion’s share of that football and men’s basketball, where the other student athletes are not necessarily making much money, but they’re getting pressure from their family members, their friends, like, why are you why don’t you have a deal with Nike yet? You’re kind of a fast cross country runner. We see you running all the time. Why aren’t you able to execute on this? Remember Nick Saban, we talked about this a long time ago on some episode. Uh, Nick Saban, former coach of Alabama towards the end of his career, said something like, my conversations with recruits like night and day just switched to like, how much can you pay me? It was like, how much playing time am I going to get? Like, who’s going to like, what can you develop? What skills can you help me develop? Like for like his whole career, then all of a sudden it’s like, can you, can you top six hundred thousand? Because that’s what I’m getting from LSU or whatever. You know, it largely attributed to why some coaches like him stepped out of the game altogether and just said, I don’t want to deal with this. Which I can I can understand that. Yeah. And we’re even seeing it affect their future career potential, where we have some football players make it into the NFL and they’re saying, well, I don’t like it here. This isn’t working for me. That’s a good point. And you’re you are an employee now. There’s no transfer portal at this stage. You’ve got to figure out how to make it work. Um, and yeah, we’ve seen people try to go back from the NFL to college, which is insane. Yeah. That was not on my bingo card. That was not on anyone’s bingo card. Yeah. That LSU thing was crazy, wasn’t it? I mean, they they even got to the point where the SEC was considering voting LSU out of the conference, which that would have been, I assume that was mostly performative, but still guaranteed. But still, just the fact that it was even out there just blew my mind. Because, you know, who’s been such a fixture in that SEC environment? I was just shocked. So you kind of brings home just how big of an impact this is, the very foundation of, you know, these hundred year traditions in college sports are like up for grabs. Um, you also mentioned kind of the entrepreneurial side. Frank and I were talking yesterday about an article that was in The Athletic a week or so ago about like where this money is coming from. So all these millions of dollars, like some of it’s coming straight from the directly from the universities now, but the big payouts still tend to come from where the big payouts have always come from in college sports. The, you know, wealthy booster types used to be delivered in the form of bags. Bag man. Yeah. Here’s your McDonald’s food full of, you know, bag stuffed full of cash. Now that was Tennessee. Now it’s out in the open. But, um, it’s an interesting change there, too. Like the motivation for giving money in the past, most of these boosters would give money kind of indirectly to the programs, and they’d get a building or something named after them that would have their name on it in perpetuity. Now you’re given these piles of money to eighteen year old kids that might be gone in a year. It’s risky. It’s transitory. Like when even if it works out great, when they’re gone, they’re gone. They don’t carry your name, like the ego incentive is gone, but it has not stopped the flow of money at all. I’m curious. I don’t know if your research has looked into that side of the equation at all, or if you just have any thoughts in general, but what motivates the the big money that these players are getting? Where’s it coming from and what are the people who give it? Are they just serious superfans and they just want to win championships? Is that is it that simple? Some of it is. And Charles Barkley has a great quote. Of course, Auburn guy too. So you have to make sure he gets some and some source of good quotes. Yes. Uh, but he’s like, I have given probably more money to Auburn over the years illegally and legally. Um, and I don’t have an endless piggy bank. Like, I can’t just keep giving out money every year to subsidize the basketball team or the football team to bring in their next star. And so, yeah, some of them will have a spot where they burn out donors or they burn out these relationships Because it doesn’t pan out, or you spend a bunch of money and then you have a eight and five football team and no one’s happy. I think the other side of it that I’ve spent a little bit more time paying attention to is that your Nil is your brand and who you say yes to, who you attach and bring money in from is very important for those student athletes to understand, and that it is okay to say no. Um, we have some student athletes at Texas State that are struggling with the sponsor telling them no. If they ask them to do social media post or create a video, and they don’t know how to do that outside of their normal social media activities, they don’t know how to make a marketing campaign from scratch. They put in this effort and then they don’t get the contract money, or they don’t have a good positive relationship with that potential employer, that potential contract. And that is a problem for Texas State. It’s a problem for the student athlete. Um, and so again, kind of back to that training of when do you say yes to a contract? What are the terms you’re agreeing to? Um, and some of the bad actors, they put some really restrictive terms of you can’t work with anybody else. It’s not just you can’t work in sports drink. You, you are locked in as our athlete or our representation for that team. So contract law, understanding those entrepreneurial opportunities, um, and realizing you can say no to the money. Um, if it doesn’t make sense for you at that time. Are all conversations they’re not really having, they’re just trying to make the most of the situation they can. Yeah, that actually does bring up an interesting point, right? You’ve got all these athletes who are now getting approached by these sponsors and donors, but they probably don’t have the understanding of the legal side and who to even engage as a lawyer. And I feel like there’s probably an opportunity, a negative opportunity to take advantage of these individuals just because they don’t know. Right. And I don’t know how much you’ve seen of that or heard of that, but it seems like that’s that can be rife right now. It is. And athletic departments are hesitant on their compliance side to give individual advice, especially on Nil deals, because it is supposed to be outside of the department and in the collective. Um, so they will maybe say, yes, you should definitely have a lawyer read this. But then that’s the financial burden of the student athlete now going out and getting a lawyer to be able to read something, paying them. And that was bye bye. That was the I don’t know if this is still the case, but like in the very early days of now, that was required, right? That the university could not be involved. It had to be outside transactions or at least the NCAA as much as they wanted to wanted to stay away from. Yeah. And that’s why it’s going through, you know, more of a national legal component, because they don’t want to be the one that puts that framework in place and then monitor it. I don’t blame them. Yeah, it kind of sounds like HR, right? You ask them about the benefits packages. Which one do you think works for me? No, we can’t tell you that. Yeah. it just seems to be the university answer of anything, right? Yeah. And for decades, their whole, um, program was built around recruitment and then development. And now it’s recruitment, development and retention. And they just don’t have the language or the coaches don’t have experience with, you know, how do I get this guy to stay? I used to be able to make him go run stairs and, you know, do a thousand burpees. And that was just part of, you know, your indoctrination into the culture of the program. And now they can say, well, I really don’t like that. And I’m going to leave. And they don’t have a good toolkit of how to navigate that relationship to say, well, we really need you to stay. Yeah, that’s that’s interesting. You can’t really flip that switch. Like, you know, that that’s just been the culture of coaching forever. Say, okay, now we’re, we do things totally differently. Like the whole personality that gets you into coaching is the type that will make, you know, run stairs. Like it’s like that kind of, uh, what would you call that? Like a. Team building. Sure, the polite way of putting it kind of militants like leadership style tends to go along with coaching. And I know something like I went to University of Connecticut for undergraduate, and that’s kind of like the basketball coaches, men’s basketball coach kind of brand is that he’s like, I still act that way. Like, I still make him run stairs, even though I realize now there’s a risk to it. It’s like, but I tell them that up front, like, I’m going to be the old school coach that like rips your head off when you screw up. But guess what? We’ve also played for three championships in four years. So if you want to, you know it’s up to you. Take it or leave it. But not every coach can do that. You know, if you’re at like a mid-tier program, whatever sport you’re in, you don’t really have that cachet to say like, yeah, I know you can leave for a bigger paycheck somewhere else, but I’m still going to be a hard ass, for lack of a better word. Yeah, I think they’re working really hard to build the infrastructure so the coach can focus on coaching instead of having to manage the program. And now they can have somebody that’s dedicated to, hey, here’s where you can go for an opportunity. Here’s how we can work on like mental health and exhaustion. And those things are important. Now that we’re adding this extra burden of you need to make money or you should make money or you’re making a lot of money. Um, and so athletic departments are trying to figure out how do we hire and build that part into our infrastructure. So is that why we’re seeing like general managers and sports? College sports now? Absolutely. Yeah. And I think Bill Belichick is a great kind of case study of how he was able to set up such an effective program with the Patriots and work really well with the GM. And then as he’s kind of stumbled a little bit and now finding his footing in the college space, I think the GM has helped a lot because it’s allowed him to say, this is what I want to focus on. This is what needs to be, you know, not on my desk. Um makes sense. Andrew Luck’s doing the same at Stanford. Yeah, that was the example I was thinking of was Stanford. Yeah. It almost seems like it has to go that way at this point. I think so. I think they need to run a lot more like a business, and I can’t think of a group of people that maybe would be really great to tap into, besides management and entrepreneurship scholars to help navigate that. But getting athletic departments to email me back has been. I was just about to say, I mean, it’s amazing how underutilized the College of Business is by a university generally. I mean, it’s like, hey, we’ve got marketing. And yet they refuse to use the marketing students. We have HR students. They refuse to kind of integrate them into, you know, it’s a, we’re supposed to be a learning institution, right? And it’s like, hey, we can develop students by engaging them in these activities and also help the university at the same time. And yet, my gosh, do they really try to stymie that, don’t they? That’s actually another good spooky thing that you don’t want to hear, like we’re talking about before. We’ve hired external consultants to do, stuff we totally have in house knowledge for. But we know you’re not going to like where this goes, so we’ve outsourced it. I don’t know if you remember at Florida State, they did that. It was like two hundred and fifty thousand dollars to examine the, the, the, the brand, right? The, the name all to get down to the College of Business. Dear God, it’s good work if you can get it. I was like, man, I would have done that for fifty grand. We would have put two hundred thousand back in the coffers. MM. What could have been. Sorry I took that in the wrong direction there. Um, but yeah, it is, it does seem like maybe we have the resources to. I mean, on the other hand, I want no part of this. Like this is just such a mess that. Well, I do think that brings us to the other side of it too. Right. This is going to certainly leave a lot of schools behind, more so than it ever has. I think we’re seeing a lot of parody today, but it’s really among like the top twenty twenty five schools versus the whole depth of like, for example, the FBS. I mean, not every school is going to have these deep pockets of the donors, and much less are they going to be able to hire all those ancillary individuals to make this work. I think that’s the challenge is that the, the structure that you’re talking about that needs to be built and maintained. Like that’s, you know, you can find like a one off donor to give a one time donation, but to sustain that, all that infrastructure, that’s got to be really hard for all but the, you know, the big brand schools and you have to find a way to, to figure out what your program is going to be. Um, if, if you’re a Georgia or Alabama and Auburn, you’ve kind of got your identity already established as a contender, um, throwing Auburn in there just for love, necessarily contender. Uh, but other programs like Texas State, we’ve got to figure out an infrastructure that goes beyond athletics, that encourages kids to come. Um, we’ve had some great stories out of, you know, the NCAA March Madness of student athletes starting their own businesses. They have vending machines on campus and they, you know, run this small business operation or Libby and, you know, l s u one of the highest grossing, you know, n I l athletes ever. And she has leveraged that into a whole career that she’s also brought her family back into to help as her employees. So they’re using the Nil money to like seed these business things. That’s cool. Yeah. So another opportunity is like, um, these student athletes don’t have a space for like a traditional internship. They have a summer training schedule. They have to get through. They have other blocks of time that they can’t dedicate three months to go get this corporate experience. And so what is nil working with a brand, figuring out how to complete a project and then having the results and the feedback from that. And so, you know, we’ve been trying to develop toolkits that are maybe a little bit more consultant based, but it’s like, hey, here’s a thirty, sixty, ninety day window of here’s where the contract started, here’s the midway report, and then here’s like the outcome of the campaign so that they can take that and say, hey, future employer, only less than two percent of NCAA athletes go pro. Here’s how. I also have some work experience that I can leverage. That’s not while I was on captain on the tennis team. Yeah, I’m thinking of those two. Uh, I think there are volleyball players from USC. Maybe. I think they n I l transferred actually to Miami. Uh, they’re like twin sisters or something. And they built this whole, like, massive side business, basically. Uh, I, I didn’t really follow too closely. They had like big, uh, social media thing going. I don’t know, they’re making a lot of money. Like, but they had, they developed this whole world for themselves outside of the sport. Yeah, they did social media, but they also did like venture capital almost where they were investing into other small businesses and brands. As part of their deal, they were getting shares of equity. And yeah, just another element that is a really cool opportunity. But also they just don’t know how to talk about equity or what that means unless they have that help. It almost seems like they’re I want to say it should be a requirement, but like, kind of like to what you were talking about before having sort of like a, a minor, like a course of study that goes along with this, that, you know, if you’re getting nil money, you take these classes, may they count towards whatever degree you’re getting to, but to just kind of point people in the right direction so they’re not just completely floundering and like buying their seventh Lamborghini because they don’t know what else to do with all their money. What we’ve tried really hard to do is find a way to translate this out of athletics as well. So Nil has unlocked the door. It’s created the marketplace for, you know, the dollar amount, how much these brands mean to these, um, the student brands mean to other brands and having them represent them. And so if you have a very entrepreneurial student or if you have somebody that’s, you know, working for, you know, music or arts, they can do a very similar playbook to what Nil is. There’s no nothing stopping you from going and getting a sponsorship from a coffee shop or nothing stopping you from going and working with a local business to help them with their marketing. And most of them kind of have that slush fund budget where they can do some fun side projects and see if it works. Um, so again, as AI and just the general hiring trend is making it harder for entry level employees to get that experience. This is a way for students to work on a kind of project based but externally focused thing that they can have results from and they can get paid for. Um, which maybe helps alleviate them having to work part time, full time while they’re a full time student or, you know, they alleviate the burden of just not having that entry level experience and then floundering a little bit on that first step into the job market. That’s something I had never thought of before. Applying this outside of sports, you know, how many students at any given college are like talented singers or something? They play at a bar every Friday or something, and they go on to be like semi-successful musician musicians or something like that. Like there’s no reason this couldn’t also work for them too. Yeah. Fashion design has been one of our biggest areas where they are great at building these brands, but they just kind of have struggled with, how do I make this seem legitimate? Or even some of the younger ones that are doing the influencing? It was always kind of seen as well. That’s a nice hobby. Yeah, that’s cute that you do that. And now it’s within IL and college sports making it legitimate. It also helps lift them up as well. Sure. That’s really cool. Yeah. Bright side to all this for sure. And audience, if you guys have any questions, please do not hesitate to to raise your hand and the India will come by with the microphone. Thank you, India, for being our our microphone person for the fourth time. She’s been our crowd worker. Thank you. Thank you for this amazing insights and amazing interview. Um, I something that bothers me about Nikhil, uh, you guys mentioned is there are some supporters of the programs that do it by heart for hard because they want their teams to win and because all this process is so opaque. Um, whereas universities are public institutions and, and then with the advent of gambling, getting into their call sheet and all those different platforms, like what we see on the weekends and like the, the, the intersection of like, I always ask the question, like, how is someone getting the returns? Uh, and when yeah, like Charles Barkley said, like, I don’t have an endless pit, but, uh, yeah, it’ll be interesting to see that. You know, we’ve had this. I believe it was Texas Tech quarterback, uh, found gambling and all and banned by NCAA. Um, if you have any thoughts on that. Yeah, we’ve been looking a lot at sports gambling and sports gambling data because it’s also a problem for just our average student where it just seems so easy to, you know, on a Saturday, just kind of look through the games and click on your phone and let it go through. Um, and then it becomes a really quick problem. I think the Texas Tech quarterback even said like, I was just bored. Like, I like it was just something I was kind of doing on the side and yeah, and I owe money that was able to gamble quite a bit. Um, it’s also really hard on the student athletes because, you know, we’ve had fantasy football in the NFL and other sports for a long time. And we know how uncool the fans can be when, you know Patrick Mahomes doesn’t throw the three touchdowns I need that weekend to win my fantasy football matchup. And now that’s happening at the college level where, you know, we’re paying you two million dollars to be here and we expect you to beat Oklahoma or we expect you to beat Texas. And it doesn’t happen. And now they get their social media and the things that they use to build their brand flooded with really negative attention. Um, or, you know, you have them in a commercial right after they throw an interception and they get this kind of negative ill will built up towards them and they have to deal with that for the whole week. Um, so like Arch Manning, I think is a great example of just how much pressure he has on him, not only from a family legacy name, not only from, you know, UT being a huge program, but just how much pressure they put on him to execute. And he’s doing fairly well. But because the spotlight’s on him, every mistake is, is magnitude magnified. So yeah, I don’t have a good answer for the sports gambling, but we are looking at that in some of our studies because it is available and because you have exact lines. How much confidence do I have? They’re going to execute or not. And then what’s the the feedback after you don’t meet that line of what people are expecting or hedging their bets on, and what do they call that prop betting where you bet on just random stuff in the course of a game, as the game is in progress, you can just keep placing bets on like someone’s going to throw an interception with five minutes left in the third quarter or something. It’s it’s not good. It incentivizes all the wrong things. And then you add all this Nil money to the pot. Yeah. I think that Texas, Texas Tech example you mentioned was a good one for people who aren’t aware. Uh, I can’t remember his name, but, uh, he’s like probably doing jail time, right? Like he was like betting on his own team. And I mean, it definitely ruined his career. His career. Yeah, yeah, he was probably on an NFL route. And then, um, yeah, now he’s, I’m sure he will find his way back through to a different team at some point, maybe. But that’s pretty toxic stuff, though. If you’ve been shown to bet on your own sport, like Ask Pete Rose. Um, I was just about to bring up Pete Rose. Yeah. Um, you know, with good reason. The sporting world doesn’t look kindly on that. I mean, I get it, it’s Halloween, and. But we still can’t raise people from the dead. Rest in peace, Pete Rose. But, you know, we can still we can still admit him to the Hall of Fame. Agreed. Yes. Yeah. I think the sports betting is an interesting angle to that. Um, it’s got to be so much harder to track than, like, back when Pete Rose got busted. Right? You know, you’ve got all these apps now and you know, what is it? What is all the varieties that are out there now? And, and it seems like, you know, you’re giving a bunch of eighteen to twenty two year olds, seemingly unlimited cash than what they’re used to. What else are you going to do? I mean, you know, some do buy those Lamborghinis. Then they go to Miami and get them all stolen. But, you know, there’s still, you know, there’s this is a big challenge I’m sure that they’re trying to deal with. And I’m sure it’s way more than just the Texas Tech quarterback. Oh, definitely. And trying to flip it to the positive. We’ve thought a lot about the way that you think about gambling and the odds and the potential payback. Um, and putting all the parlays together. Mhm. That’s also kind of managerial thinking where you think of your cost benefit analysis. And so if you can put it into kind of an odds ratio, you might be a little bit more comfortable with. Well, let’s take this risk here because, you know, it’s plus three hundred. We could see a pretty big kickback here. But that one’s plus twelve hundred. That’s actually probably too big of a risk for our comfort zone. So just a different way to think about problems and how you assign risk might be a good way to at least use the skill set while still talking about the dangers and the addiction of gambling that it can be. I think reviewer two has some concerns. Well, my concern, I don’t know if this is true. I will never touch those sports betting apps because I know myself too well and I think I that’s just not a rabbit hole I want to be anywhere around. But my understanding is if like, if you’re good, like you understand like expected value and calculating odds, like they will just shut you down. Like, even if you’re like, not immediately successful. If they detect that, you know, what you’re doing from a gambling perspective, they will just close your account. Yes. You don’t want your business. Yeah. I’ve talked to several that also make markets like they, they set their own lines and their own prop bets. And so I think it’s a really interesting area of somebody that makes their own kind of marketplace with these bets. I didn’t know you could do that. That’s interesting. They also talk about his whole goal is to be successful sixteen days of the month and the other fourteen or fifteen days he’s failed. Um, so it’s just a very hard lifestyle for professional gamblers to live. Um, and, you know, deal with that much failure to try to just be successful fifty one percent of the time. Yeah, that’s an interesting way to think about it. But yeah, it’s almost any kind of investing is that way. Like you just try to win a little bit more than you lose. And most of the time you’re going to lose, especially to the professionals. The average person is not going to make. Yeah. That’s why I just invest in Voo. Um, it just it just keeps going up slowly surely. What is Voo. It’s a it’s an S&P five hundred sort of broad market. Oh the the ETF. Yeah. The Vanguard. Okay. I thought it was virgin olive oil. It’s that too. I mean you know it’s a good investment especially when you’re the FSU mafia. Any other questions from the audience? Yeah. So, uh, you mentioned the fact that, uh, universities that don’t have a robust Nil Hill pool. It’s going to hurt them, right? So you’ll you’ll see these smaller schools talk about, um, the coaches talk about how they’re training their players to and they’re going to go to another school. So I don’t not actually going to put too much awful much time in them. Right. I mean, they, they, they believe in, in training these. We’ll talk football training these young men to be better football players. Right. But they also know that that person’s leaving. I think the interesting thing is the bigger schools where you do have that parity in n I l you are seeing the parity and outcomes too, right? So Alabama’s not stacking, you know, fifteen five star running backs anymore. They have two five star running backs. And those guys go down there. You know whoever that that two star that’s sitting there on the bench. They’re starting now right. And you’re seeing that parity the SEC. I just the stats. You know Kentucky’s at first in the SEC. And then there’s a like ten schools that have two losses right. So you have these like institutional outcomes from this much more micro economic, um, change, right. I think that’s pretty interesting for college athletics as a whole. It’s this idea of parity. I have no idea who the good football teams are now. Yep. Right. I mean, if Indiana can go wire to wire and win a championship, like out of out of nowhere, uh, it’s a different world. That was thanks to Mark Cuban. You know, he, uh, he’s like, I’m buying Indiana. Um, but, you know, Paul, you mentioned something. That was Paul Johnson, not not Paul Harvey. Uh, you mentioned something very interesting, though, about the, uh, the investment in time and certain players and, you know, they’re going to transfer. You wonder how much that’s going to stunt their growth and their NFL potential to if they’re, if they’re being like this, right? Because, I mean, if you’re not, if they’re not investing the same time in you from a coaching perspective or even like they know you’re going to leave because maybe you’re not getting the starting time you once did, that’s kind of have some sort of stunting effect on your career and your aspirations? Absolutely. Like it’s just kind of a peer network kind of theory problem. We’re seeing it a lot with especially offensive linemen and defensive linemen. It used to be that next guy up or next girl up, uh mentality. And when that goes away, you’ve got a huge gap in your, your whole structure. Um, we’re also looking at worker runs where it’s like your star quarterback leaves. Who else is leaving with him? Um, are they going to different schools for different reasons. And so yeah, you have all of a sudden this huge culture shift where, you know, when a head coach gets poached, that obviously has its repercussions. But now you have players that are dictating kind of the culture shift of that as well. Um, so my hope and what I’m thinking it’s going to move towards is that as we start to develop these cultures, you’re going to have your NCAA journeymen who are going to recognize that they probably don’t have NFL potential or don’t have pro potential. So they’re going to make as much money as they can in college sports. Others are going to try to use it to build either their Nil empire and have a small business that they use and leverage to build from this, or to maximize their skill and potential on the field by having that consistency. So I think that’ll start to become part of the recruiting conversation. The Oregon State wide receiver that said, he’s going back. He did get paid to. But it’s part of that. You know I work really well with these coaches. I like where I’m at. And that story will be attractive to some recruits. Um I think that’s what Dabo Swinney is still holding out for at Clemson is that hey come here for this reason and and grow and build with us. It’ll just be a while until the dust settles. Yeah. Do you think Dabo is going to make it long enough for that to happen? It’s not looking good. No. Not looking good. Um, but yeah, it’s it’ll depend on how much tolerance the fan bases have to. And that’s where that pressure and that tension of we’re not we’re going to withhold our money. We’re not going to give you, you know, that access to that revenue to to bring in the players until you make a change really has a big impact on, on the system and the, the culture you’re trying to build. And, you know, another interesting thing is, um, there are a lot of schools have capabilities to, let’s say, pay top dollar for a quarterback, whether it’s Carmody or Taylor at Mississippi State or, you know, you know, sellers in the South Carolina. But you know, these kids, they are competitive athletes that they’ve been competing all their lives and they want to win too, right? So I think associating themselves, being paid and winning and being just paid and losing and not winning as much. And then how does that impact their development? Because again, you know, there is this emotional part as well and how resilient you are. So I think, uh, It’s it’s, it is amazing. And also, I mean, I still remember before I moved to UTC, the Cinderella run, we had like winning n I t and the best players that we had, they were amazing shooters in the basketball program. And then they are not there anymore. So like it just changes the whole landscape of, well, what is the pipeline going to look like? And, and then are there some schools like, I think there are some schools in Miami elite or something. They are just focused on athletic training, like they’re better than others. Are they going to be the the future pipeline or like how it’s going to impact all this? I think that’s really, really interesting. Yeah. Yeah, I, I think that’s a, that’s an excellent point and, uh, probably a good one that we, we sort of end with any, any, I have one final question is, how can Frank and I, uh, get paid with this nail stuff for our podcast. Is that like a thing we can do? Oh, yeah. Absolutely can. Yeah. Um, the hard part is that you just kind of have to know your brand and your pitch, just like any other entrepreneur would. Um, that sounds like a lot of work. Yeah. It is. And that is the thing. It is a lot of work. That’s just too much busyness for me. Too much busyness. So. Well, hopefully we’ll set up the infrastructure so we can get some students to go out and do it for you. That would be great. And they get the experience. They get the experience. You get the you get the bags of cash. Okay. If you find some students that are in need of, uh, of a group to work with, we’re here. So just keep that in mind. Uh, Jake, thanks so much for your time. Our audience, thank you so much for your time. Thank you for your questions. And yeah, thanks for the questions, involvement, and thanks to India for for being our mic person for the fourth year. Third year. I don’t I don’t even know at this point. Paul. Good day. Good day. Frank. 


Leave a Reply